The other night we saw "I am Legend." I still have really mixed feelings about it. I spent a good portion of the movie knowing the dog was going to die. Because I knew that (it was obvious), I couldn't really enjoy the movie because I kept waiting for the dreaded event. It did happen and I wept quietly. Other people in the theater, including grown men, wept openly and loudly. I suppose that is the sign of a good movie, to create that much of an emotional response. Still, I am not a person who likes to have or display a lot of emotions publicly, especially those of sadness. Frankly it makes me uncomfortable. Even much later when Britton and I were discussing the movie I found myself very near tears when we discussed the dog and I mentioned that it wasn't the attack that bothered me so much as Will Smith giving the dog that shot and holding it in his arms and singing to it. Yes, I know it isn't real and yet I can imagine doing very much the same thing. So yes, as far as myself being able to relate to the main character in this movie and having an emotional response, it worked. However, the sadness it made me feel might have very well overshadowed the movie itself, at least for me. I will never be able to think of that movie without thinking of the dog and the sadness her death made me feel.I wish I could say that I enjoyed the movie, but that isn't a term that fits. It was, in a sense, a good movie and yet I didn't really leave the theater feeling good. Honestly I felt somewhat traumatized.
I wonder if I would have had the same response if the dog had been a human? To be honest with myself and everyone -- I doubt I would have. Oh, it would have still been sad, but not as sad. Dogs are just more lovable than people, they are also more loving and more loyal, for the most part. They aren't humans and they aren't vengeful, or cruel and they give unconditional love. That doesn't mean humans can't have moments of unbelievable bravery, self sacrifice and love, but they still have a lot to learn about such things.
4 comments:
I haven't seen I am legend but I expected it to be the case with the dog, it's the same thing that ruined Peter Jacksons King Kong remake for me, I knew the big guy was going to die and spent the whole movie choking back the emotions waiting for the final moments.
With human death, well I'd say I see maybe 20 deaths on TV each day.
Indeed. I felt the same way about King Kong. It is also one of the reasons I no longer read Stephen King books, if there is a dog in it and he takes time to make you like the dog, it will die.
That's why I refuse to see "I am Legend" I knew that would happen. No...any movie with a dog that figures into the plot I will not watch. There's enough pain and misery in the world.
Strange how this is. I feel the same way about animal suffering, much worse for me than the innumerable news stories about man's inhumanity to man. Whenever there's an oil spill I absolutely have to skip the agonizing shots of oil soaked wildlife.
Post a Comment