The UFO topic is marginalized because of "researchers" like Jacobs and Hopkins who run around, messing about with people, and then claiming that aliens are abducting hundreds (or is it thousands, or millions??) of people around the world (despite the fact that the vast majority of abduction reports seem to come from the United States).
The real conspiracy of silence has been the failure of "ufology" to disassociate itself from the alien abduction cult, and the whole idea that the ETH is a proven fact.
I somewhat agree and also very much disagree. I am going to mostly skip the part about Jacobs and Hopkins, except to say that I am not a big believer in regression hypnosis. That said, it is occasionally used by law enforcement to help people remember details of crimes, though I am not quite sure if it is allowed in court, more so to help the police with leads I think. Also, UFOlogy is not marginalized because of those types of people, but because the other people don't care about it and do no research into it.
Alien abduction cult? I am not sure what that is. Hypnosis aside, there are people that claim to remember being abducted. Really there are quite a lot of them. I am not going to say they are being abducted by aliens, but something is happening to them and don't say sleep paralysis - it just isn't a good enough answer for all such experiences. I don't know about the cult, it seems like most of Ufology seems to try very hard to ignore these claims, so I assume Paul is speaking of some fringe element. There are fringe elements of everything including science, we can't waste time worrying about them. To that point, there is no way for Ufology to disassociate itself from the fringe or any alien abduction cult because really there is no such thing as Ufology. There are people that research UFOs, which you can't call a science because there are no repeatable results and only a few cases with real testable evidence. In the world view, UFOlogy is a big tent that covers a variety of things including alien abduction, but I don't think most people are so stupid that they think everyone in that tent sees things in the same way. Maybe a few stupid people, the same ones that think all Republicans are members of the Tea Party and all Democrats want to kill babies. Again, we can't worry about people that have no depth and do no research.
I also disagree that most of Ufology treats ETH as a proven fact. There are a few people that feel they have seen enough evidence to prove that to themselves, but I don't even think they are the majority of Ufology anymore -- maybe several years ago that was true. Myself, I believe there could be a variety of answers as there is also a variety of experiences. I think much of the problem comes when people feel they need a real answer so they pick what is the most likely answer to them. I don't need any real answers and rather enjoy considering all possibilities, but that is not everyone's cup of tea.
6 comments:
Hi Lesley,
When I say that most of "ufology" treats the ETH as a proven fact, I am referring specifically o what I would call "mainstream" ufology, i.e. those people like Stan Friedman, or Kevin Randle. And yes, amongst that group, which is generally the one that gets the most public play, the ETH as ETFact is definitely the majority opinion. And those are the serious ones - the less serious crowd (or, as I have called the, Friedman's intellectual children), such as the exopols, definitely hold that view. The general public, insomuch as they are aware at all of the UFO phenomenon, associate it with the ETH largely because of these people, both the serious and non-serious ones. I doubt you would be able to walk down a city street and find anyone familiar with Vallee, or even Keel. Friedman, on the other hand, is a different matter; even Steven Bassett, given his appearances in the mainstream media, or someone like (ugh) Jeff peckman or Stan Romanek. But that is what the ETHers as ETFacters have created.
As for whT I call the "Alien Abduction cult," hey, if Stan can refer to the SETI "cultists" then I think it's fair game to refer to the "abductionologists" and their adherents as cultists, because they exhibit the same type of behaviour (with more damaging consequences to real people, I would add, then SETI ever could). If anyone is interested, I have written about this subject on more than one occasion - the most concise version is at: http://redstarfilms.blogspot.com/2007/01/alien-abduction-cult.html
As for hypnosis and courts, I know of no court in the anglo-saxon legal tradition, i.e. Canada, the UK, the USA etc., that would admit hypnotically induced testimony for the veracity of its contents, although I am happy to be corrected on that point.
Paul
Fair enough. I am aware that Stanton and the others that believe that, just pointing out that I don't think they are the majority of Ufology anymore, even if we include the exopolitics people.
As I said, I don’t know that regression has ever been allowed in court (something I may look into though, it would be interesting to know for certain), but I do know that police sometimes used it to help witnesses remember details of crimes, but I am not actually sure if it is still used for that either.
I agree abductee claimants are being manipulated and exploited by some "researchers" for their own profit and fame.
Alien abduction likely has more to do with human psychology and the human brain than extra-, interdimensional-, crypto-terrestrial, or paranormal involvement in human affairs. Working with abductees John Mack had an opportunity to break new psychological ground, but I think he failed because he became too wrapped up in their stories and didn’t dig deeper.
Two things always strike me about alien abduction . . .
1. It happens to people in the US (as noted by you and others) so there has to be a socio-cultural underpinning to the alien abduction belief system (and there IS one . . . usually about interbreeding or showing us a terrible future coming unless we change our ways).
2. Many abductees' stories seem to be disguised memories of their own birth experience (the bright light, being helpless, being lifted in the air, being put on a table, being examined by one or more beings, etc.). Just think about what happens to newly delivered infants in the average US hospital delivery room and you'll know what I mean.
Anyway, food for thought . . .
Hi
I just posted a short essay on this subject that examines the manipulation, misdirection and propagandizing that substitutes for science and while we all attempt to be respectful of another worldview,other than our own, I count myself among those who are losing interest due to the fact the field of "Ufology" is more miss than hit and is "stewed, pickled and preserved in aspic".
I agree with Mr Kimball to some extent, but at the same time, I am reminded of R.A Wilson who observed we all tunnel and edit reality...but at the same time,I think a great deal of material when you brush away the dust, is simply exploitation, pure and simple as well as rancid.
Sad but true. I think all this is largely a result of a very effective ploy of "containment" where we are all labeled as fringe or lunatic, by the viral insertion of fear. How many topics are called "alien deception" or "trickster" phenomenon when we are perfectly capable of deceiving ourselves? Or being manipulated into being pawns simply to spread around the contagion of self destruction by saying this person is that versus that one is this..in a game of postulates that are all relative. Alien threat? We have met the enemy and they are us.
Quite capable of deceiving ourselves. I actually know a few people that when they tell their "abduction" stories, it is obvious to me that they are unknowingly fabricating it in a way that helps them to deal with a different trauma or helps them to explain that trauma. I would never point that out to them because it would anger them and wouldn't change their minds about what they are "sure" happened, but it seems obvious for some observing from the outside of the situation.
As I often say we are all woo-woos by someone's definition.
"Also, UFOlogy is not marginalized because of those types of people, but because the other people don't care about it and do no research into it."
True. Also, UFOlogy is marginalized because it's UFOlogy. It will always be marginalized.
Post a Comment